Cranberry Yogurt Custard Tartlets

This recipe was created out of a desire for custard tartlets, combined with a need to use up leftover cranberry sauce and a ton of open tubs of yogurt that were reaching their expiry.

They were such a hit among my friends and family that I decided the recipe should go up now, just in case you have, like me, an abundance of cranberry sauce leftover from Christmas dinner. (In case you missed it, you can catch my cranberry sauce video here.)

The pastry I use for these custard tartlets is based on a classic sour cream pastry. I replace the sour cream with yogurt, but if sour cream is what you have, you can use it in place of the yogurt. I also swapped out some of the all purpose flour with whole wheat because I like the flavour and texture it gives.

The filling on these custard tartlets is tangy, not too sweet, and bakes into a silky smooth bite of heaven.

These custard tartlets are the perfect little treats to bring to a party, or to entertain guests at home. Because they’re not too sweet, so they would be welcome on any table alongside cocktail snacks or desserts.

If you don’t have leftover cranberry sauce to fill them with, you can use any homemade or store bought jam or marmalade instead.


Cranberry Yogurt Custard Tartlets

Makes 24 regular or 48 mini tartlets

For The Pastry

  • 200g All Purpose Flour

  • 60g Whole Wheat Flour

  • 1 tsp Salt

  • 2 Tbsp Sugar

  • 225g Butter - room temp

  • 125g Full Fat Yogurt

Contrary to most pastry recipes, the butter should be close to room temperature for this recipe. Room temperature butter is easier to work into the flour with your fingers. Somehow, magically, this dough is flaky and tender every time. Like most pastry, this dough should be chilled before rolling it out.  

For the Yogurt Custard

  • 400g Full Fat Yogurt

  • 4 Eggs

  • Zest of One Orange

  • 1 oz Bourbon

  • 100g Sugar

  • 1 tsp Vanilla

  • Pinch Salt

Whisk the filling ingredients together until nice and smooth

To Make The Tarts


Roll out the chilled dough until it’s about 3mm thick. Use a cookie cutter or a glass to cut rounds that will fit nicely into the tins you are using. The ones I used are the little mini muffin tins that come 24/tin.

Fit the dough rounds into the muffin tins. If the dough is getting too warm, chill the whole tin for 5-10 minutes before filling.

Fill the tartlet shells with the yogurt custard to about two thirds full.

Drop one blob of leftover cranberry sauce onto each tartlet, so that the shells are almost full but definitely not overflowing. Leave a little margin at the top.

Bake the custard tartlets at 350 for 20-25 minutes. They’re ready when the middle looks jiggly but set.

You can keep these guys on the counter for a day, but if you’re leaving it overnight or longer, put it in the fridge. I’d recommend eating it ASAP though. The fresher the better!

I hope make these and enjoy them as much as I do! Be sure to let me know how they turn out.


Make Better Dinners!

Sign up for a weekly email from me! You'll receive tips, updates, and general dinnertime encouragement.

    I won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.