Extra Creamy Cheesy Pasta With Butternut Squash

Share the love!

This Cheesy Pasta With Butternut Squash is my favourite version of mac & cheese. The butternut squash makes the creamiest sauce, and the real cheese makes it perfectly cheesy. Of course, if you wanted to make this into a vegan recipe, you could swap out the cheese for vegan cheese.

close up of cheesy butternut squash pasta in a bowl.
Butternut squash makes the creamiest sauce!

I’m not a huge fan of hiding vegetables in food. I know it’s easy for me to say because I was never a picky eater and I’ve never had to feed a picky child either. But even if I did, I don’t think I would try to hide vegetables from them. 

When I hear people say things like “You can’t even taste the vegetables!” It’s kinda like when teenagers say “you can’t even taste the alcohol!” in their vodka iced teas or whatever. 

But once in awhile a concept comes around that presents itself like a healthier “hidden vegetable” substitution for the real thing, and it turns out that it’s actually better than the real thing. 

I think this is the case when using butternut squash in a creamy cheesy pasta sauce.

A pot and some bowls of butternut squash pasta.
Don’t be afraid to make a big batch. It stays super creamy in the fridge!

Mac and cheese is the ultimate comfort food, and butternut squash is your ticket to an easier and arguably better mac and cheese than the original milk-based one.

Butternut squash makes the best cheese sauce! Here’s why:

  • Butternut squash are orange, which is a colour that we often associate with cheesiness. (Even though orange cheese isn’t naturally orange, it’s dyed with annatto seed, but you get the point.)
  • Butternut squash is SUPER creamy. Just what you need for a creamy cheesy sauce.
  • Squash (especially roasted butternut squash) have a delightful sweet flavour that works perfectly against the flavour of tangy cheese. 

I’d say that this cheesy pasta is a great way to celebrate the butternut.

Why I love this Cheesy Butternut Squash Pasta recipe

I love this recipe because it’s easier and more hands-off than a standard white sauce. AND, instead of congealing into a cheesy dense block in the fridge overnight, It stays smooth creamy! 

Stovetop or baked?

For this recipe I use a stovetop method instead of baking it in the oven. I prefer the stovetop method because it keeps the pasta as creamy as possible and removes the risk of it drying out in the oven. I also like this method because I end up with fewer dirty dishes at the end of the day. (I don’t love scrubbing cheese-crusted casserole dishes, but that’s just me!)

If you decide to bake your pasta to get a crispy melty cheesy top, I’d recommend not to bake it for more than 15 minutes or you’ll risk it drying out.

*If you’re making this in advance and reheating it, the baked method can be a good option. See the section about storage, freezing, and reheating below.

What about the crispy topping?

If I am in the mood for a crispy topping, I like to toast bread crumbs in olive oil in a cast iron pan until they’re crispy. I season them with salt and black pepper, and occasionally throw a bit of garlic in there too. You can make your breadcrumbs cheesy by stirring in some grated parmesan cheese after they have cooled slightly.

How to make this Cheesy Butternut Squash Pasta

The method for this lovely cheesy pasta recipe is simple.

  1. Roast the squash: Preheat the oven to 375 (or 400 if you want more browning), Toss the butternut squash and onion in some olive oil and salt, and roast for about 25 minutes or until tender. 
  2. Cook your pasta until al dente, and set it aside while you finish your sauce. 
  3. Blend the sauce: Blend up the squash, onion, some cheese – I like a combination of gruyere, cheddar cheese, and Parmesan, and a few tablespoons of cream cheese or butter. Use enough cooking liquid to thin out the sauce just right, then toss the cooked pasta with the sauce. The sauce can be blended in a food processor or blender. I used a Vitamix because I just got one and I’m really excited about it. It also makes the smoothest sauces in the land. 

*NOTE: This butternut squash pasta could easily be made gluten free if you choose some gf noodles, and if you go that route, you can sub out the bread crumbs with salt and pepper seasoned ground almonds. (And get some cheese in there too if you like!)

Storage, freezing, and reheating

This Cheesy Pasta With Butternut Squash makes for some top notch leftovers. To store it in the fridge, cool the pasta completely before refrigerating in an air-tight container. It should last for up to 4 days that way.

This pasta also freezes really well. To freeze it, chill it thoroughly and wrap tightly or cover with a tight-fitting lid and freeze for up to 1 month.

To reheat the refrigerated pasta, you can either bake it an oven-safe dish until the internal temperature reaches 165 degrees, or you can reheat smaller portions in the microwave as needed.

To reheat the pasta from frozen, defrost it overnight in the fridge first, then bake it in a covered, oven-safe casserole dish until the internal temperature reaches 165 degrees. This should take 45-60 minutes.

creamy butternut squash mac and cheese in a bowl

Creamy Cheesy Pasta With Butternut Squash

This Creamy Cheesy Pasta With Butternut Squash is the creamiest mac and cheese out there! Butternut squash is the perfect addition to make a super silky (still cheesy) mac.
5 from 2 votes
Prep Time 15 mins
Cook Time 30 mins
Course Dinner
Cuisine Comfort, Vegetarian
Servings 6 servings
Calories 493 kcal

Ingredients
  

  • 800 grams butternut squash (approx. 1 squash)
  • 1 onion, medium
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • 2 teaspoons salt
  • 450 grams dry pasta
  • 1 teaspoon garlic powder
  • 1 pinch grated nutmeg
  • 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard
  • 4 tablespoons cream cheese or butter
  • 150 grams grated cheese. I like a blend of Swiss and Cheddar

Instructions
 

  • Preheat the oven to 375 degrees
  • Peel and chop the squash and onion, toss with olive oil and salt, and roast for 25-30 minutes or until tender.
  • While the squash is roasting, cook your pasta in plenty of boiling salted water until al dente.
  • Drain the pasta and reserve the cooking water. Set the pasta aside.
  • Once the squash and onion are tender, transfer them to your blender or food processer and add the cheeses, mustard, spices, and 1 cup of the pasta cooking water.
  • Blend, and add more cooking water as needed until the sauce forms a creamy consistency.
  • Add the sauce to the cooked pasta and stir to combine.
  • Serve with crispy bread crumbs and whatever condiments your heart desires. For me, it's hot sauce, black pepper, and ketchup.

Notes

  • If you have added too much of the pasta cooking liquid and your sauce is too thin, turn it into a baked mac and cheese! It’ll thicken up in the oven.
  • Nutrition

    Calories: 493kcalCarbohydrates: 74.3gProtein: 18.2gFat: 14.3gSaturated Fat: 7.3gCholesterol: 34mgSodium: 990mgPotassium: 705mgFiber: 5.6gSugar: 6gCalcium: 272mgIron: 4mg
    Keyword pasta
    Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

    3 Comments

    1. Pingback: 3 Ways To Use Nutritional Yeast (Besides Popcorn) | How To Make Dinner

    2. 5 stars
      This recipe is soooooo creamy and delicious! And super easy to make 🙂

    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.